Lobster Roll At Madison Square Eats

Now you can read us on your iPhone and iPad! Check out the BTRtoday app.

Another beautiful day, another outing to Madison Square Eats.

For days now, I’ve been fantasizing about a lobster roll. That rich, yummy, shell-fishy, buttery goodness oozing onto the perfect All-American receptacle, the hot-dog bun.

Here’s the thing: Lobster Rolls are damn expensive. Especially the one featured at Redhook Lobster Pound, which sells for a whopping $18.00, pre-tax. Yikes. I told myself I’d resist. I told myself I would opt for something which wouldn’t hurt my pockets quite so acutely.

But, when my coworker informed me that she’d be getting a Lobster Roll, it broke my resolve. I was helpless. There was nothing I could do. The first step is admitting that you had a problem.

There are three styles one can choose from: Maine (chilled lobster with homemade mayo and lemon), Connecticut (warm lobster with butter, lemon, paprika, and scallions), and Tuscan (chilled lobster with basil vinaigrette.)

I always say yes to butter, so I opted for the Connecticut style roll. Every bite was heaven. The decadent lobster was perfectly cooked, and the bread toasted to perfection- -It absorbed the juicy buttery goodness like a champion.

Despite the deliciosity, though, I found myself unsatisfied. This shit was expensive, and at the end of the roll, I was still hungry. And I couldn’t buy another $18.00 roll, I just couldn’t.

What’s a girl to do?